When I hear about people becoming “emotionally addicted” to this stuff that can’t even pass a basic turing test it makes me weep a little for humanity. The standards for basic social interaction shouldn’t be this low.
Reminds me of this old ad, for lamps, I think, where someone threw out an old lamp (just a plain old lamp, not anthropomorphised in any way) and it was all alone and cold in the rain and it was very sad and then the ad was like “it’s just an inanimate object, you dumb fuck, it doesn’t feel anything, just stop moping and buy a new one, at [whatever company paid for the ad]”.
I don’t know if it was good at getting people to buy lamps (I somehow doubt it), but it definitely demonstrated that we humans will feel empathy for the stupidest inanimate shit.
And LLMs are especially designed to be as addictive as possible (especially for CEOs, hence them being obligate yesmen), since we’re definitely not going to get attached to them for their usefulness or accuracy.
For a while I was telling people “don’t fall in love with anything that doesn’t have a pulse.” Which I still believe is good advice concerning AI companion apps.
But someone reminded me of that humans will pack-bond with anything meme that featured a toaster or something like that, and I realized it was probably a futile effort and gave it up.
Yeah, telling people about what or who they can fall in love with is kind of outdated. Like racial segregation or arranged marriage.
I find affection with my bonsai plants and yeast colonies, those sure have no pulse.
I personally find AI tools tiring and disgusting, but after playing with them for some time (which wasnt a lot, I use local deploy and free tier of a big thing), I discovered particular conditions where appropriate application brings me genuine joy, akin to joy from using a good saw or a chisel. I can easily imagine people might really enjoy this stuff.
The issue with LLMs is not fundamental and internal to concept of AI itself, but it is in economic system that creared and placed them as they are now while burning our planet and society.
Damn, this made me laugh hard lol
When I hear about people becoming “emotionally addicted” to this stuff that can’t even pass a basic turing test it makes me weep a little for humanity. The standards for basic social interaction shouldn’t be this low.
Humans get emotionally addicted to lots of objects that are not even animate or do not even exist outside their mind. Don’t blame them.
Reminds me of this old ad, for lamps, I think, where someone threw out an old lamp (just a plain old lamp, not anthropomorphised in any way) and it was all alone and cold in the rain and it was very sad and then the ad was like “it’s just an inanimate object, you dumb fuck, it doesn’t feel anything, just stop moping and buy a new one, at [whatever company paid for the ad]”.
I don’t know if it was good at getting people to buy lamps (I somehow doubt it), but it definitely demonstrated that we humans will feel empathy for the stupidest inanimate shit.
And LLMs are especially designed to be as addictive as possible (especially for CEOs, hence them being obligate yesmen), since we’re definitely not going to get attached to them for their usefulness or accuracy.
Oh my god!! Late, but I actually wrote a psychology/neuroscience report on that ad once in college LMAO
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBqhIVyfsRg
The lamp ad, fwiw
Also, since there is no relevant XKCD, there has to be a relevant Community (yes, it’s a law):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z906aLyP5fg&t=7s
For a while I was telling people “don’t fall in love with anything that doesn’t have a pulse.” Which I still believe is good advice concerning AI companion apps.
But someone reminded me of that humans will pack-bond with anything meme that featured a toaster or something like that, and I realized it was probably a futile effort and gave it up.
Yeah, telling people about what or who they can fall in love with is kind of outdated. Like racial segregation or arranged marriage.
I find affection with my bonsai plants and yeast colonies, those sure have no pulse.
I personally find AI tools tiring and disgusting, but after playing with them for some time (which wasnt a lot, I use local deploy and free tier of a big thing), I discovered particular conditions where appropriate application brings me genuine joy, akin to joy from using a good saw or a chisel. I can easily imagine people might really enjoy this stuff.
The issue with LLMs is not fundamental and internal to concept of AI itself, but it is in economic system that creared and placed them as they are now while burning our planet and society.