This is basically gap moe the anime so far. I’m having some trouble with the predictability of the gags and, especially, the FL’s predictable reactions even though the actors are fun and I like the cast. Time will tell if it’ll get more clever but I really want to like it!

Oh yeah, looks to be a really solid adaptation. The biggest upside is that the animation is in service of character and personality, and there’s a lot of it.

Here’s the opening, btw! Folks seem to like it a lot.

Helluva good episode. What a cliffhanger, though! Brother is already in a pinch.

Not a bad second episode. Looks like the show will move quickly enough during the three-episode rule that people will have time to figure out Maki’s not the derivative ML that he was made out to be (specifically, by the anime crew and their insistence on a more generic style) in the first episode. Fingers crossed, this is a good series, with cool interpersonal insights!

Yeah the anime seems to adapt the look and feel of the manga down to a T. Best job at that this season, methinks. Can’t vouch for the manga, I’ve read less than 10 chapters, but looks to be light and fun.

Hey, awesome. I’m with you on all these criticisms. Let’s see how it plays out with the next episode. What I really just wanted to try to hint at is that there is a similarly deep dynamic between the main characters of Class de 2-banme as there is with Gals Cant’t Be Kind, and it would be a huge shame if the anime fails to show it.

It’s kind of crazy how derivative the first episode looked like, but it made me realize how hard it is to properly translate the little tiny bits in the manga that make it work work. It is really subtle in delivering the overall cozy feel. It makes me think of Fujichika Koume’s manga, actually, especially Tonari no Onee-san ga Suki, which was ultra hyper duper subtle, and to a lesser degree Suki na Ko ga Megane wo Wasureta (the adaptation of which was handled ok-ish by Go Hands even if there were super odd moments in the animation at times).

That’s also making me feel really hyped about Gals - they got the personalities suuuper right out of the box even if I had some tiny nitpicks about the style.

Yeah, Koyun can’t even begin to wrap her head around as to why Minato would even try to approach her. It simply all seems fishy to her, lol. That’s why Minato is going to have such a hard time doing his usual thing.

It’s actually really funny to see Koyun go thru the various alternative behaviours she can think up in real time, trying to see what might work in a particular situation. Nothing comes naturally any more since she’s shut herself out. And yet she’s completely natural with Youta already, so it isn’t that she can’t - she’s just overthinking everything.

I think the way you framed the characters is really good, it’s as if they all have something the others don’t. Youta has his issues, too, but we just haven’t seem them yet :)

I love how vitriolic your take is on the Class de 2-banme anime. I do think its first episode absolutely lacked in the finesse of the manga. Absolutely. I can see how it came off.

Let’s say it wasn’t just the line art, like here, but rather the whole look of the series had changed ever-so-slightly for the worse - nothing too offensive, it still looks ok, but it just happened to become more run-of-the-mill - which then made cute and clever look simply stereotypical to a watcher that knows to look for tropes. The hook was definitely missing.

If I hadn’t read the manga and loved it, I might’ve stopped at episode 1 too. But I just want to show you a few pages from the chapters that the anime adapted: Maki being discombobulated, Asanagi playing with Maki, Maki worrying about trying to be a friend.

I do think it has a light, cute touch all its own, and doesn’t shy away from seriousness either, even if the drama is relatively light, much like in this show. It also couldn’t be further from a harem, lol. I know what you mean, but don’t we all want Gals Can’t Be Kind

Back to your point about warmth, specifically, I would say the same goes for Class de 2-banme too. I think I’d give it a few episodes, or check out the manga if you like to read. It does have a big heart, too. Thanks for the additional info on Klutzy & Short as well.

Woo! Season 2 in the summer. See you then!

One of my favourites too. This season is a little too stacked, TON of great manga adaptations this season. Are you watching anything, in want of recommendations from a particular genre?

There was a ton of it to carry the character over. The girls move with personality unlike in most other shows!

I’m not as high on the animation as you are, as I’d have preferred the line art to look as thick as it is in the original. The look and feel is simply less “inked” as I’d like, but I do agree that the animation is good. I especially like that there is a lot of it to carry over the character. I too have been reading this right from the start, and it’s been consistently in my top favourites all that time. We are in for a treat for sure.

Are you watching Class de 2-banme ni Kawaii Onnanoko to Tomodachi ni Natta too? It’s just as good a series and the adaptation looks to be on par with this one. The Klutzy Class Monitor and the Girl with the Short Skirt looks to have the best art out of the current rom-com adaptations, but I’m less familiar with the manga, so I can’t vouch for the story there.

She’s great! The author of this manga has a fantastic knack for fully rounded characters, including but not at all limited to the leads. Polar Opposites is very similar to this show. You’re in for a treat in case you haven’t seen it. It’s a show where pretty much everyone you’d like to has a story.

I was a little uncertain about the pacing and tone of the first half of the first episode, it felt like they were going too hard trying to set up the show. But I see now that it simply was a difficult task to get things going, the manga is very subtle and has a ton going for it.

This second episode is already on top of things and the humour is starting to show through. I’m already super looking forward to the third episode, much in the same way I was with the anime of the author’s other series, Polar Opposites. I’m pretty sure this is going to be as good.

I would say that Minato and Koyun are in similar ruts, just from the opposite angle. Minato doesn’t know how to stop, and Koyun doesn’t know how to start. I am loving how her dumbfoundedness is animated, it’s much funnier here than in the manga.

I am a huge fan of this manga, having followed it from the very beginning, but was coming in very cold due to the look and feel of the anime not quite matching that of the source material. The main characters are all a little off.

The Klutzy Class Monitor and the Girl with the Short Skirt, for instance, does a great job of translating the look and feel, and this one just doesn’t. The original has an understated look all its own that I’ve not seen elsewhere.

Still, I warmed up enough at the end of the episode that I’ll continue watching, gripes or no gripes. It’s a great series, after all.

Wow, this is great! I’ve seen a bunch of these before but never in a more concerted effort. Looking forward to it.

Yeah figured xD

I didn’t much care for the student council focus either. I did like the show up til that point, though, and while I heard there’s going to be more of the council shenanigans in the next season, I’m still going to give it a go. If it’s more of the first half of the season, then might as well watch, and if it’s more of the second half, then it’s a drop.